| Sheriff | Years Served |
|---|---|
| Shaun Golden | 2010 – current |
| Kim Guadagno | 2008 – 2010 |
| Joseph W. Oxley | 1996 – 2007 |
| William M. Lanzaro | 1981 – 1995 |
| Paul Kiernan | 1966 – 1980 |
| Joseph A. Shafto | 1962 – 1966 |
| Ira E. Wolcott | 1947, 1949 – 1951, 1953, 1956-1963 |
| John T Lawley | 1941 |
| Morris J. Woodring | 1938, 1941, 1944 |
| George H. Roberts | 1935 |
| Howard Height | 1932 |
| William R. O’Brien | 1929 |
| Narry N. Johnson | 1926 |
| John H. Van Mater | 1920,1923 |
| Walter H. Gravatt | 1920 |
| Elmer H. Geran | 1917, 1920 |
| Cornelius B. Barkalow | 1914, 1918 |
| Wilbert A. Beecroft | 1911 |
| Clarence E. F. Hetrick | 1908 |
| Charles E. Close | 1905 – 1906 |
| Charles Asa Francis | 1905 |
| Obadiah C. Bogardus | 1902 |
| Obadiah E. Davis | 1899, 1902 – 1905 |
| 1856 | |
| Jordan Woolley | 1862 |
| Joseph J. Thompson | 1859 |
| Samuel P. Forman | 1799 |
| James Lloyd | 1796 |
| William Lloyd | 1793 |
| Elisha Walton | 1790 |
| Daniel Hendrickson | 1788-1789 |
| John Burrowes | 1784 |
